Radical New Hypothesis For Why Humans Exist

My Comments: from time to time my mind tends to wander. Some of you might argue it’s much of the time, but at least it wonders.

This may not sit well with some of my friends who believe there is an insurmountable chasm between their faith and the world around them but , for me, it’s another chapter in my quest to fully identify myself.


Where do we come from? Well, it depends on who you ask. For example, an astrophysicist might say that the chemical components of our bodies were first forged in the nuclear fires of stars.

On the other hand, an evolutionary biologist might look at the similarities between our DNA and that of other primates’ and conclude we evolved from apes. Lisa Randall, a theoretical physicist at Harvard University, has a different, and novel answer, which she describes in her latest book Dark Matter and the Dinosaurs

Randall has written other popular science books including The New York Time’s bestseller, Warped Passages: Unravelling the Mysteries of the Universe’s Hidden Dimensions. Her studies at Harvard explore theoretical particle physics and cosmology.

In her latest book, she posits that the extinction of the dinosaurs – necessary for the emergence of humans – is linked to dark matter. Dark matter is the mysterious, invisible matter that astronomers estimate makes up 85 percent of all matter in our Universe.

One species’ extinction is another’s head start

Palaeontologists largely agree that about 66 million years ago a giant, 14.4-km-long (9-mile-long) celestial body – likely a comet – struck Earth. The impact wiped out 75 percent of species across the planet, including most of the dinosaurs.

Amongst the survivors were small primates. Over the next 66 million years these primates diversified, grew larger, learned to walk on two legs, and developed large brains, which they eventually used to invent pizza delivery.

So what caused that giant space rock to collide with our planet in the first place and give primates a chance to thrive? It could just be chance – or luck, depending on your perspective – but Randall would disagree with both of these ideas.

In her book, Randall describes a dark, pancake-shaped patty of densely packed dark matter within our galaxy that could be responsible for our emergence as a species. Dark matter has never been directly detected. However, there is enough evidence for its immense gravitational influence on our Universe that the vast majority of the scientific community agrees that dark matter is a form of mysterious matter that we can neither see or touch, but that nevertheless must permeate the cosmos.

Generally, dark matter tends to be concentrated in large halos around galaxies like giant bubbles. But Randall thinks that there could also be a flatter, denser region of dark matter amidst the stars, planets, and gas clouds in our galaxy.

Beware the dark disc

If there is dark matter in Randall’s hypothetical disc, then it stands to reason that the disc has a powerful gravitational influence on the objects around it – including our Solar System.

But our Solar System is not always near the disc, which is the crux of Randall’s theory. As the Solar System revolves around the centre of the Milky Way – the same way Earth revolves around the Sun – it moves up and down, or oscillates, through the plane of our galaxy. And the rate of this oscillation is very intriguing.

Below is an illustration of our Solar System’s oscillation where the orange dot in the lower left rectangle is our sun and the black line at the centre is the dark disc:

A team of astronomers made a rough estimate of this oscillation rate near the turn of this century, calculating that our Solar System passes through the plane of the Milky Way about once every 32 million years, which means if there’s a dark disc, we pass through that at the same rate.

Interestingly, there’s evidence to suggest that mass extinctions in Earth’s past happened within this time frame, or about once every 25 to 35 million years.

It’s this similarity between the rate of mass extinction rates and the rate of our Solar System’s oscillation through the galaxy that made Randall and her Harvard colleague Matthew Reece first suggest the link in scientific paper published in the journal Physical Review Letters last year, and that Randall explores more in her book.

Randall hypothesises that when we’re passing through the dark disc, the gravity from the dark matter within influences the outer region of our Solar System, called the Oort cloud. The Oort cloud, illustrated below just right of centre, sits about two light years from the Sun and is thought to contain billions of icy objects at least 19 km (12 miles) wide.

If something 19 km wide hit Earth today, it would mean the end of life as we know it. And Randall thinks that’s exactly what happened to the dinosaurs 66 million years ago that opened the door for widespread primate evolution.

While it’s impossible to wind back the clock, proving the existence of the dark disc would greatly advance Randall’s theory. She’s tried to do so by looking at the speed and direction of stars in our galaxy. If stars moved in ways that couldn’t be explained by the amount of ordinary, visible matter around them, then it could suggest the presence of the dark disc.

But that’s a very tall order. There are about 100 billion stars in the Milky Way, and hunting dark matter is notoriously tricky.

We have a dozen or so functioning detectors underground, on Earth’s surface, and in space – and none of them has yet managed to sniff out a dark matter particle. If they do, it would be a significant step toward supporting Randall’s hypothesis.

In her concluding remarks, Randall writes:
“In some global sense, we are all descendants of Chicxulub [the town where the dinosaur-killing meteor impacted]. It’s a part of our history that we should want to understand. If true, the additional wrinkle presented in this book would mean that not only was dark matter responsible for irrevocably changing our world, but also that some of it played a crucial role in allowing our existence.”